Welcome to Holidaypac Cardboard Display and Packaging Factory!

From Price Objection to Partnership – How Holidaypac Turned a Simple Shelf Pusher Test into a Long-Term Opportunity

Holidaypac
2025-11-20
2658

From Price Objection to Partnership – How Holidaypac Turned a Simple Shelf Pusher Test into a Long-Term Opportunity

When Urbanpulse, a Lithuanian retailer, reached out to Holidaypac about shelf pushers for their refrigerators, it sounded like a straightforward hardware request.

 

In reality, it turned into a great case study in listening carefully, designing the right solution, and handling sample pricing without killing the deal before it even started.

 

1. Client Background

Urbanpulse operates refrigerators where they display:

Each refrigerator has:

Their vision was clear:Use one refrigerator to showcase several product dimensions, while keeping everything front-faced, organized, and easy for shoppers to see.

 

To do that, they needed adjustable shelf pushers from Holidaypac that could handle:

From Price Objection to Partnership – How Holidaypac Turned a Simple Shelf Pusher Test into a Long-Term Opportunity

2. The Challenge

On the surface, “I need pushers for my fridge shelves” sounds simple.

But once we at Holidaypac started asking questions, the real challenges appeared:

 

Multiple product sizes on the same shelf

 

      Protein bar 1: 33 mm width x 19 mm depth

      Protein bar 2: 39 mm width x 15 mm depth

      Can: 65 mm diameter

      Carton box: 150 mm x 102 mm

 

That’s a big spread in dimensions for one system to cover.

 

Visibility requirement for cartons

 

     Urbanpulse didn’t just want boxes to sit flat.
     They asked if the carton boxes could be slightly tilted so customers could more easily see what’s inside.

 

Low-volume, high-impact stage: Proof of Concept

 

    This was only for a POC (proof of concept).

    If everything worked, they would roll out to many more refrigerators.

    But for now, it was a small test order — meaning:

         Sample costs and shipping had a huge impact on their decision.

         Any mistake in design would be expensive and slow.

 

For Holidaypac, this was not just a hardware quote. It was a chance to prove we can support smart merchandising and long-term rollouts, starting from a tiny pilot.

 

From Price Objection to Partnership – How Holidaypac Turned a Simple Shelf Pusher Test into a Long-Term Opportunity

 

3. Our Approach: Holidaypac’s Step-by-Step Method

Instead of throwing a generic solution at the client, Holidaypac walked through a structured process.

Step 1 – Clarify the scenario

We asked Urbanpulse to:

 

      Share pictures of their products (bars, cans, carton boxes)

      Confirm how the products would be packed:

             Would cans have outer boxes?

             Would protein bars be in display cartons or loose?

             Would carton boxes be sealed with stickers so they don’t accidentally open?

 

This helped us understand not just “what size,” but also:

Step 2 – Match each product type to a Holidaypac pusher

Based on the dimensions provided, the Holidaypac engineering team:

 

    Recommended a pusher width range that could be adjusted to fit:

        Protein bars

        Carton boxes

        Cans

We suggested:

This modular approach gives:

Step 3 – Test tilting for carton boxes

The client asked:“Is it possible to position carton boxes a bit tilted so customers can see easier what’s inside?”

 

At Holidaypac, we:

The conclusion:

 

    Standard pushers are not designed with an internal slope

    Boxes could be placed in a sloping orientation, but:

        Too much tilt risked ruining the composition inside

        There was a trade-off between visibility and product stability

 

That’s why we recommended:

4. The Sample Pricing Objection

Once the technical side looked promising, the conversation shifted to money.

For the POC, the client wanted Holidaypac to provide:

Our initial rough breakdown:

The all-in number:

For the client, this triggered two issues:

 

     Sample price felt too high compared to bulk

     From their perspective, the sample unit cost was about 5x the projected bulk price, which didn’t match their past experience with other suppliers.

 

    VAT applied on total cost

    In the EU, they had to pay 21% VAT on the full invoice amount – including shipping.

    That made the landing cost for a small test set even more painful.

 

They gave clear, professional feedback:

 

From Price Objection to Partnership – How Holidaypac Turned a Simple Shelf Pusher Test into a Long-Term Opportunity

 

5. How Holidaypac Responded: Transparency + Flexibility

Instead of becoming defensive, Holidaypac:

 

    Explained the reality behind the cost

        For special samples, the actual production cost per unit is higher:

 

            Small quantity manufacturing

            Extra manual work

            Time spent on engineering and testing

            Shipping for a small box internationally is relatively expensive per unit.

 

    Confirmed the long-term intent

        We recognized that:

 

        This wasn’t a one-off curiosity purchase

        Urbanpulse was considering these pushers for larger volume deployment across more refrigerators

 

    Adjusted the pricing model

        To align better with the client’s expectations and industry practice, Holidaypac:

 

              Anchored the price to a realistic bulk unit estimate of about USD 2.51 / pc

              Offered sample pricing at only 30% higher than bulk:

                  USD 3.26 / pc for samples

                  For 4 pcs: USD 13.04 (excluding shipping)

 

This moved the conversation from:

“Why is this 5x more expensive?”

 

to:

“Okay, this looks fair for a sample that reflects the bulk price structure.”

 

The client’s response was positive: they asked Holidaypac to redo the proforma invoice with the revised sample pricing.

 

From Price Objection to Partnership – How Holidaypac Turned a Simple Shelf Pusher Test into a Long-Term Opportunity

 

6. Outcome: A Better Foundation for a Long-Term Deal

Even though this stage was “just for samples,” the outcome was meaningful:

 

    The client felt heard and respected on pricing concerns

    Holidaypac protected realistic cost structure (instead of dumping samples at a loss)

    Both sides aligned on:

        A fair logic for sample vs. bulk prices

        Next-step testing in the client’s real refrigeration environment

 

Just as importantly, we:

This sets up the project for:

From Price Objection to Partnership – How Holidaypac Turned a Simple Shelf Pusher Test into a Long-Term Opportunity

 

7. Key Lessons for Retail Hardware & Display Projects

This case taught (or reinforced) a few practical lessons that apply to many B2B projects, especially when working with a manufacturer like Holidaypac.

1. Get real numbers early

The more detail you share, the less risk there is in engineering the wrong thing.

2. Use samples, but be honest about their cost

Samples are not “free mini bulk orders.” They:

However, if you:

you reduce friction and build trust — which is exactly what Holidaypac aims for in every pilot project.

3. Treat price objections as collaboration, not conflict

Urbanpulse’s objection to the sample cost wasn’t an attack. It was:

By listening and adjusting:

From Price Objection to Partnership – How Holidaypac Turned a Simple Shelf Pusher Test into a Long-Term Opportunity

 

8. How Holidaypac Can Help with Your Next Project

If you’re a retailer or brand planning to:

this case highlights a simple roadmap:

  1. Start with real data – dimensions, photos, and use cases
  2. Prototype smartly – test a handful of well-chosen Holidaypac samples
  3. Negotiate transparently – align on sample logic vs. bulk
  4. Think in terms of partnership – both sides invest a little more up front to avoid costly mistakes later

If you’d like a similar consultative approach for your own shelf or display project, Holidaypac is ready to help. Bring clear measurements, real products, and honest budget constraints — and we’ll work together from there.

Hot products

read more

FAQ

read more

In this page, HolidayPac will show the cases how holidaypac supply the packaging and cardboard displays and other related products solution for our clients.  To save the communicated time cost and make the solution in a high effect to save our clints time cost. HolidayPAC try to be a global packaging factory, solution expert in paper and paper related products, like, paper packaging, cardboard displays, PDQ, and air fryer liners, pharchment papers. 

Contact Us

Holidaypac Packaging and Display Co.LTD Facebook link twitter youtube linkedin Pinterest Instagram Tiktok
Xiamen Holiday Paper Product Co.,Ltd

Contact us

Please fill out the form below and we will get back to as soon as possible

Send Email Chat with Whatsapp